Carter's Cantina Menu

Carter’s Cantina invites you to savor authentic Mexican flavors in New Haven, MI, with a menu that bursts with vibrant tastes and comforting classics. From their zesty Street Tacos and hearty Chimichangas to inventive delights like Cheesecake Nachos and the bold Mexican Pizza, each dish tells a story of tradition and creativity. The House Margarita and Blue Margarita stand out as perfect companions, elevating every bite with refreshing sips. The Combo Platter offers a satisfying sampler, while fan favorites such as Tacos Al Pastor, Shrimp Tacos, and the warming Chicken Tortilla Soup showcase the kitchen’s commitment to quality and balance. The menu’s versatility extends to kids, with tasty options like Nacho Chips topped with cheese or tender Chicken Tenders, ensuring family-friendly appeal. Whether you crave a light appetizer like Guac and Chips or a hearty Burrito Bowl, Carter’s Cantina harmonizes bold spices and fresh ingredients in every dish, leaving a memorable mark on every visit.